Model No. 1516: [?]

Model No. 1516

Model by: NGH or JBH?
Made when: 1870 (???)
Possible model scale: 1/24
Model length (ca.): 43.6" (110.8cm)
Implied vessel LOA at 1/24 (ca.): 87' 3" (26.6m)
Power/Sail: S
Hull Configuration: Keel
Model location: H.M.M. Workshop North Wall Center

Original text on model:
"[Blank]" (Source: Original handwritten annotation on model. Undated.)

Model description:
"The model is glued to a mounting board. There are separate pieces of wood for the stem, keel/skeg, u/w hull, topside, and deck. There is no writing on the back of the mounting board.
Model dimensions- LOA with bowsprit 49.25 in. LOA with stem piece 43.625 in. LOA of hull w/o stem 43.313 in. B 5.1 in. D 5.5 in." (Source: Palmieri, John (Curator Herreshoff Marine Museum). Email to Claas van der Linde, October 14, 2010.)

Model identification:
"Model 1516 represents a LOA/Beam ratio of 4.28, which, judging from L/B ratios of known early Herreshoff-built yachts, would point to a vessel of some 80ft LOA or even longer. #187303es Faustine with an LOA of 79ft 6in was the only sailing vessel longer than 70ft LOA that was built by the Herreshoffs before Gloriana of 1891. Faustine had a LOA/Beam ratio of 4.042 which is quite close to this model. However, at the most likely used scale of 1:32 (3/8" to the foot) this model would represent a vessel of 87.25ft LOA (w stem) or 86.63' LOA (w/o stem) and 20.4' beam, which seems to be too large to be a match for Faustine.
Note, that a Herreshoff-built model of Faustine at the New York Yacht Club is 29.75in LOA and 3.5in beam, representing a LOA/Beam ratio of 4.25 and, at a scale of 1/32 an LOA of 79.33ft and beam of 18.67ft.
There appears to be no early Herreshoff-built vessel matching this model's dimensions at any of the commonly used scales.
Note, also, what NGH once wrote in the context of his having modeled #187106es Shadow: '... One year before the Shadow was built I cut two preliminary ones of her same character --- notably a schooner yacht about 90ft. long, which model can now be seen. ...' (Source: Herreshoff, N. G. 'Shadow.' Forest and Stream, September 15, 1887, p. 154.) Might Model 1516 be the model alluded to by NGH?" (Source: van der Linde, Claas. December 3, 2010.)

Herreshoff Catalogue Raisonné.
All rights reserved. No reproduction, adaptation, or distribution of any part of this document or any information contained herein by any means whatsoever is permitted without prior written permission. For the full terms of copyright for this document please click here. Last revision 2018-01-01.
© 2018,

Citation: Herreshoff Model 1516 [?]. Herreshoff Catalogue Raisonné.